League titles are often considered the ultimate mark of greatness in football. It’s the long, grinding battle of consistency across months, with triumph and heartbreak in equal measure.
Despite all the accolades and memories, there is just something poignantly poetic about a world-class player who never manages to win a league title. It’s like a highly regarded actor who never wins an Oscar- his brilliance remains undoubted, but there’s just that one elusive merit hanging over him.
Some of the greatest-ever footballers found themselves in this situation, where despite turning fans’ heads with their impressive skills, leading their teams to various cup competition victories was what remained within reach of those greats, while a league trophy continued to be out of reach.
So, let’s look at the top 10 soccer players who never won a league title despite their greatness on the field.
1. Steven Gerrard
- Clubs: Liverpool, LA Galaxy
- Best Seasons:
2013/14: Liverpool – 2nd place, Premier League
2008/09: Liverpool – 2nd place, Premier League
It’s almost impossible to think of “Gerrard” without the word “slip” springing to mind the unfair fate of one of the finest midfielders the Premier League has seen.
Gerrard was Liverpool’s beating heart for almost two decades, hauling the side to countless victories, including that never-to-be-forgotten 2005 Champions League final.
He had it all: leadership, vision, tackling, long-range goals, and the capacity to set Anfield alight with a single pass. And yet, that Premier League title always eluded him.
Perhaps the closest Gerrard would ever get to the clutches of that elusive title was the 2013/14 season.
Liverpool, under Brendan Rodgers, was supposed to end their drought of league titles, until that fateful slip against Chelsea derailed their hopes.
Gerrard, ever loyal to the club which made him a legend, resisted opportunities to join other top clubs that might have secured him a title.
Even across his move to LA Galaxy, a league title never came his way. For all his brilliance, Gerrard’s career has become a reminder of just how cruel football can get.
2. Stanley Matthews
- Clubs: Blackpool, Stoke City, Toronto City
- Best Seasons:
1950/51: Blackpool – 3rd place, First Division
If you’ve never heard of Stanley Matthews, allow me to enlighten you: this man played professional football until he was 50. Yes, 50!
They didn’t call him “The Wizard of the Dribble” for nothing. A career spanning just about three decades really was a feat of stamina and genius. Yet, despite his awe-inspiring talent, a league title never came his way.
He spent much of his career with Stoke City and Blackpool, two clubs that gained periodic splutters of brilliance but never had the firepower to win the First Division.
The best chance he had was indeed with Blackpool, which finished third in the 1950/51 season.
Still, Matthews did not need a league title to secure his legacy — those dazzling dribbles and then that mythical performance in the 1953 FA Cup Final, also labelled as “The Matthews Final,” would have printed his name in the archives of football forever.
3. Bobby Moore
- Clubs: West Ham, Fulham
- Best Seasons:
1958/59: West Ham – 6th position, First Division
Few defenders in football history possess the stature that Bobby Moore does. This is the man who captained England to their only World Cup victory in 1966, forever immortalizing him as one of the greatest players in English football.
Despite his international success, his domestic career curiously lacks any league silverware.
The teams Moore played for, West Ham United and later Fulham, were never serious contenders to lift the First Division title. The best West Ham could manage during his stay was sixth place in 1958/59-to a decent position, yet still a country mile away from the top.
His elegance on the ball, coupled with his defensive brilliance made him an icon, without that elusive league trophy.
4. Socrates
- Clubs: Botafogo, Corinthians, Fiorentina, Flamengo, Santos
- Best Seasons:
1980: Corinthians – 5th place, Brazilian Serie A
Not many footballers have commanded an aura like that of Socrates on and off the pitch. He was not just a mere footballer; he was a philosopher, a political activist, and a sign of intellectualism in the beautiful game.
On the field, Socrates was commanding in midfield, orchestrating attacks with unsweat ease. Yet, for all his genius on the pitch, he never managed to win a league title.
Adding to that, the league in Brazil was structured in such a way that made winning even tougher since its ultimate champion was determined with knockout stages.
Socrates had never won with even big clubs like Corinthians and Flamengo.
His spell in Italy with Fiorentina was not something different either. Yet, much of Socrates’ legacy goes way beyond trophies, since his peculiar style of playing left a strong influence on football culture.
5. Gary Lineker
- Clubs: Leicester, Everton, Barcelona, Tottenham
- Best Seasons:
1985/86: Everton – 2nd place, First Division
1988/89: Barcelona – 2nd place, La Liga
Lineker is a name eponymous with goals, not just because of his clinical finishing, but also because he won the Golden Boot at the 1986 World Cup. His razor-sharpness in front of goal made him a feared striker in England, Spain, and beyond.
And despite such a prolific scoring record, a league title never found its way into his trophy cabinet.
Lineker came agonizingly close with Everton during the 1985/86 season, finishing a mere two points behind their bitter rivals Liverpool. There were also near-misses at Barcelona with second-place finishes in La Liga.
At Spurs, Lineker continued to bang them in, but the team never reached the required consistency for title success. Regardless, Lineker’s legacy as one of the best English strikers remains secure — with or without a league title.
6. Jay-Jay Okocha
- Clubs: Bolton, Eintracht Frankfurt, PSG, Fenerbahce, Hull City
- Best Seasons:
1999/2000: PSG – 2nd place
1996/97: Fenerbahce – 3rd place
If there’s one player on this list who epitomized flair, it’s Jay-Jay Okocha, one of the greatest dribblers in football. The Nigerian magician’s dribbling, skill, and sheer joy for the game made him a fan favourite everywhere he played. Yet, for all his brilliance, a league title never materialized during his career.
Okocha came closest at PSG, who finished second in the 1999/2000 season. At Fenerbahce, he finished third in the 1996/97 season and runners-up the following.
His footwork may have dazzled the fans wherever he was, and his creativeness might have mesmerized crowds, but it wasn’t enough to carry his teams to the summit of their respective leagues.
The legacy Okocha left is that of entertainment and individual brilliance, sans that all-important league triumph.
7. Harry Kane
- Clubs: Tottenham, Bayern Munich
- Best Seasons:
2016/17: Tottenham – 2nd place, Premier League
2015/16: Tottenham – 3rd place, Premier League
Kane is one of the most elite goal-getters of these modern times. Consistent, lethal, and tireless, Kane has been Tottenham’s shining light for more than a decade.
His goals have reaped an endless harvest of personal praise, yet a league title still remains frustratingly out of reach.
The Spurs of Mauricio Pochettino came closest, finishing as runners-up in 2016/17 and third in 2015/16, but that last step was always out of reach.
His transfer to Bayern Munich in 2023 presents another opportunity to break this title drought, but Bayern Leverkusen clutch that away from him with an unbeaten streak to win the league title.
Well, the 2024/25 season is another opportunity for him to win one, that’s if the spell is not hanging around.
8. Antoine Griezmann
- Clubs: Real Sociedad, Atletico Madrid, Barcelona
- Best Seasons:
2015/16: Atletico Madrid – 3rd place, La Liga
2019/20: Barcelona – 2nd place, La Liga
Griezmann has been fascinating La Liga fans with his versatility, creativity, and intelligence for over a decade now. On either Real Sociedad, Atletico Madrid, or Barcelona, Griezmann has ever been one of the most dangerous players on the pitch.
However, like others on this list, the league title has remained just out of reach.
The closest he came was at Barcelona when the Camp Nou outfit finished runners-up in the 2019/20 season behind Real Madrid. The first spell at Atletico also witnessed two near-misses with third and second-place finishes in consecutive seasons.
For all his brilliance, the journey of Griezmann towards any league title remains incomplete.
9. Fernando Torres
- Clubs: Atletico Madrid, Liverpool, Chelsea, AC Milan
- Best Seasons:
2008/09: Liverpool – 2nd place, Premier League
2017/18: Atletico Madrid – 2nd place, La Liga
“El Niño,” was arguably one of the most electric strikers in world football during his prime. His blurring pace, effective finishing, and knack for scoring clutch goals made him a fan favourite. Despite his international success with Spain and Champions League triumph with Chelsea, Torres never won a domestic league title.
His closest call to league glory was the 2008/09 season at Liverpool, where they finished second behind Manchester United.
He also came close with Atletico Madrid, where they finished second in La Liga in 2017/18. For all his accomplishments, that league title proved elusive for Torres.
10. Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink
- Clubs: Chelsea, Middlesbrough, Leeds, Atletico Madrid
- Best Seasons:
2003/2004: Chelsea – 2nd place, Premier League
1998/1999: Leeds – 4th place, Premier League
Hasselbaink may not be as globally celebrated as Torres or Lineker, but in his prime, he was one of the most lethal strikers the Premier League had ever seen.
With two Golden Boots to his name and over 200 goals across his career, his talent was undeniable.
Wherever he played, he found the back of the net, earning a reputation as a goal-scoring machine. Despite his brilliance, a league title always slipped through his grasp.
He came closest to the league crown during his time at Chelsea, where they finished second in the 2003/2004 season, just before Roman Abramovich’s financial revolution turned the club into a dominant force.
Before that, at Leeds, his team managed a fourth-place finish in 1998/1999, and his stint at Atletico Madrid saw the club struggle in La Liga.
No matter how sharp his finishing or how consistent his performance, his clubs never quite made it to the top
You Might Also Want To Read This
- Top 10 Best Strikers (Centre-Forward) In The World 2024
- Top 10 Goalkeepers In The World 2024
- Top 10 Right Wingers In The World 2024
- Top 10 Best Left Back In The World 2024
- Top 10 Best Right Back In The World 2024
- Top 10 Attacking Midfielders In The World 2024
- Top 10 Defensive Midfielders In The World 2024
- Leeds United’s 10 Greatest Players Of All Time
- Aston Villa’s 10 Greatest Players Of All Time
- 8 Football Clubs That Have Suffered Deep Decline
- The Number 10 In Soccer – Why It’s So Special
- 10 Of The Greatest Danish Players Of All Time
- 10 Of The Greatest Irish Soccer Players Of All Time
